An exhibition of his photographs at the Princeton Public Library in October 2014 highlighted the unsightliness and impracticality of the tangles of overhead wires and cables found in most American towns and suburbs. 6:1). [...] This artist chose to capture the Old Paris, to hold on to the relics of the past overwhelmed by the speeding traffic of the present day: the narrow cobblestone streets, the horse-drawn carts, the poor peddlers hawking their wares.” His images “were produced as documents, recording monuments and sites that were clearly identified by their image-maker; but they were published in the United States, after the photographer’s death, as art objects in a large and beautiful volume, where the images are severed from the captions that ‘fix’ them in historical time and space (the captions are listed in a separate section discreetly hidden at the back of the book).” American Pictorialism, in short, transformed the perception of the original, primarily documentary images. In those cases where the inhabitants of the slums are distinctly portrayed — sometimes in groups — and must therefore, in view of the required long exposure times, have agreed to pose, how did Annan win their cooperation? Beyond this court the second passage led to a second square court, occupied in the same way by its dunghill; and from this court there was yet a third passage leading to a third court, and third dungheap. Ibid., p. 604. Atget, it is claimed, “was a commercial image-maker” whose “photographs and albums were sold to artists, libraries, and historical societies eager to preserve the past. John Forbes Watson and John William Kaye, London, 1868-1875), Captain Hooper took a number of powerful and horrifying but carefully-composed photographs of skeletal victims of the famine (Fig. 4, 10, 99) A recent incident, reported in the London Daily Mail of a woman being beaten to death by two other women, while bystanders, instead of going to her assistance, used their cell phones to videotape the scene, provides disturbing confirmation of Sontag’s thesis. Martin Daunton (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2001), pp. E.g. 148-67. Jan 21, 2019 - Thomas Annan (1829 -1887) was the son of a Fife farmer and flax spinner and lived for most of his life in Glasgow. 6:1). Albumen print. 6:9-18). 11-12, 20-21. , in “A Plea for Straight Photography” (1904), reproduced in Peter Bunnell, ed., A Photographic Vision: Pictorial Photography, 1889-1923. V Key Plan 1 1 : 2400 This "key plan" indicates coverage of the Goad 1901 series of fire insurance maps of Glasgow that were originally produced to aid insurance companies in assessing fire risks. My photographs are intended to present something you don’t see.” (p. 200), 97 Neil Matheson, “Demand: Allegories of the Real and the Return of History,” in The State of the Real: Aesthetics in the Digital Age, ed. Damian Sutton, Susan Brind, Ray McKenzie (London: I.B. of. 6:24 Glasgow Sanitary Department, “Roslin Place and Burnside Street near Garscube Road in Cowcaddens.” 1920s. He must have explored the wynds at length, waiting for the best time of day, when light crept in. Like language it is a medium in which works of art (among other things) are made. and ed. The space separating the photograph from its object is occupied by factors making the object relative to conditions over which the process has no control. It has never been sentimental about its old buildings. , Plate 9. Revolting as was the outward appearance of these places, I confess I was little prepared for the filth and destitution within. Out of photography one can make passport pictures, weather photographs, pornographic pictures, X-rays, wedding pictures, and Atget’s Paris.131. 150-173). Open Content images tend to be large in file-size. Download a larger version of this image About this artwork. 73 Damer, Glasgow: Going for a Song, p. 76; Michael Pacione, Glasgow: The Socio-spatial Development of the City, p. 117. In a selection of Annan’s photographs of Glasgow, James McCarroll compares Annan to Jacob Riis in his depiction of slum life: “His views of the closes are genuinely moving and full of pathos. , Plate 7. In the group portraits especially, the figures represented seem to assert their humanity, overwhelmed, hemmed in and rendered fragile as it is by the somber and oppressive mass of their stony environment.120 Given that the unavoidably long exposure times required his human subjects to remain absolutely still for several minutes, Annan clearly had to win their goodwill and co-operation. “Between 1870 and 1914,” in the words of the novelist and journalist Allan Massie, “Glasgow reached its apogee. Several critics have pointed out that the decision to demolish had already been taken before Annan moved in with his camera, and that his assignment was simply to record a significant piece of the city’s past that was about to be destroyed.88 Contrary to what is often argued or simply assumed,89 it is thus unlikely, these critics hold, that he “used his camera as a social weapon,” photographing the old closes and streets of Glasgow in order to draw attention to urban blight and promote action to correct it. (Glasgow: J. MacLehose and Sons, 1900), p. 22. I call “photographic referent” not the optionally real thing to which an image or a sign refers but the necessarily real thing which has been placed before the lens, without which there would be no photograph. See also the entry on Hooper by Kathleen Howe in John Hannavy, ed., Encyclopedia of Nineteenth-Century Photography, The Victorians themselves, Annan’s contemporaries, appear to have anticipated to some extent the contemporary debate about documentary photographs that depict famine, poverty, war and other forms of human misery. 125 Zahid R. Chaudhary, After-Image of Empire: Photography in Nineteenth-Century India (Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 2012), pp. [...] The entrance to these abodes is generally through a close, not unfrequently some inches deep with water or mud, or the fluid part of every kind of filth, carelessly thrown down from unwillingness to go with it to one of the common receptacles; and in every close there is at least one of these places, situated immediately under the windows of the dwelling-houses, or together with byres, stables, etc., forming the ground floor, while the stench arising therefrom pollutes the neighbourhood and renders the habitations above almost intolerable.” (Quoted by Damer, The Complete Writings of Nathaniel Hawthorne. Atget, it is claimed, “was a commercial image-maker” whose “photographs and albums were sold to artists, libraries, and historical societies eager to preserve the past. The author apologized in his Preface for the gruesome picture his book presented of “the condition of the poor, and the classes generally inhabiting the lower depths of society,” but insisted on its honest and unembellished realism. 1858-60. 1, p. 45. 128 Saltmarket,” from Glasgow Improvements Act 1866, Plate 24. 157-71. After training and working as a copperplate… Frank Sutcliffe, the still widely-admired photographer of the fishing town of Whitby and its inhabitants in the last decades of the nineteenth century, made the point forcefully in 1890: “Is it because we have been so in the habit of going only for the labelled objects that our eyes are not sufficiently alert and our senses properly tuned to respond to the greater charms of the rarer beauties?” (Cit. V Key Plan 1 1 : 2400 This "key plan" indicates coverage of the Goad 1901 series of fire insurance maps of Glasgow that were originally produced to aid insurance companies in assessing fire risks. Even from a technical point of view, photographing in the dark closes of Glasgow must have required close attention to the conditions of light at different times of day and, in view of the long exposure times needed, to controlling the movement of people in order to avoid excessive blurring. Today, shop windows are stocked with Annan prints framed for domestic consumption and countless city centre pubs and restaurants mount Glasgow’s old streets and closes on their walls.87. Richard Howard (New York: Hill and Wang, 1981), p. 4. Thomas Annan (1829 -1887) was the son of a Fife farmer and flax spinner and lived for most of his life in Glasgow. In her Introduction to the 1977 Dover Publications edition (p. v and endnote 9 on p. xiii), Anita Ventura Mozley gives a figure of 100 copies for the 1878 album, citing information provided by Jerold C. Maddox, the Curator of Photography at the Library of Congress. After training and working as … Graphic Arts Collection, Department of Rare Books and Special Collections, Princeton University Library. Graphic Arts Collection, Department of Rare Books and Special Collections, Princeton University Library. A verbal text does not have to be defined solely by its ostensible genre or function: some historical or biographical narratives, some works of political or economic theory or of philosophy are also, by common consent, great works of literature. Huge collection, amazing choice, 100+ million high quality, affordable RF and RM images. 6:19 “The London Costermonger.” Engraving of daguerreotype photograph by Richard Beard in Henry Mayhew, London Labour and the London Poor: A Cyclopædia of the Condition and Earnings of those that will work, those that cannot work, and those that will not work. 104-05, 107. 28 Saltmarket,” from Glasgow Improvements Act 1866, Plate 21. Referring to post-World War I “social document” photography in Weimar Germany, Soviet Russia and Depression-era America, Jens Jäger drew attention to the difficulty of determining “from the images themselves whether the perspective of the photographers was conservative or socialist, or whether ultimately aesthetic considerations were decisive.” (, [Tübingen: Edition diskord, 2000], p. 111) A similar difficulty attends many earlier photographs. The interiors of these houses and their inmates corresponded with the exteriors. 36Among many examples of “documentary” photographs that have ceased to function as social criticism or even primarily as historical records and now function almost exclusively as art — or that were in fact always positioned astride the boundary separating documentation and art — one could cite the beautifully composed photographs of exploitative child labour by Lewis Hine in the early years of the twentieth century, some of the photographs taken by Dr. Barnardo and his missionaries in the last quarter of the nineteenth century, and the work of Depression-era photographers such as Dorothea Lange (Figs. Among those impressed by the absence of images of extreme squalor, one could point to the following: David Bate, “Illuminating Annan,”. These districts [...] may be considered as the fruitful source of those pestilential fevers which thence spread their destructive ravages over the whole of Glasgow.70. 1900. A work from the collections of the de Young and Legion of Honor museums of San Francisco, CA. The photographs are undeniably beautiful. Albumen print. Still, in at least one case — a view of the Palace of Linlithgow — there is material evidence that he sketched the scene he wanted to photograph and made notes to himself about lighting conditions and the best times of day for camera work. Created between 1868 and 1871 as part of a commission from the City of Glasgow Improvements Trust, this collection of images of the working class areas of old Glasgow helped document the impoverished living conditions of the working class at the time. English: Photographs from Old Closes and Streets of Glasgow by Thomas Annan. “I think the poorer classes of Glasgow excel even those in Liverpool in the bad eminence of filth, uncombed and unwashed children, drunkenness, disorderly deportment, evil smell, and all that makes city poverty disgusting.” On his second visit, his impression had not changed: “The Trongate and the Salt-Market [...] were formerly the principal business streets, and, together with High Street, the abode of the rich merchants and other great people of the town. 128 Martha Rosler, “In, Around, and Afterthoughts (on documentary photography),” in Martha Rosler, Works (Press of the Nova Scotia College of Art and Design, 1981, repr. As noted, the work of Hine and Riis also came to be valued more for its formal than for its documentary qualities. The 1878 album was to have contained “an introductory and descriptive letterpress,” but, in the event, it was put together without the planned text, which, in any case, would again not have been by Annan himself, but by the City Architect, John Carrick, an influential and energetic figure with strong ideas of his own. Other scholars give a figure of 100 copies each for both the Annan and the MacLehose publications. Wolfgang Kemp, “Images of Decay,” pp. 6:18 Thomas Annan, “Close, No. Thus, for example, the Edinburgh newspaper The Scotsman in the mid-nineteenth century: “The artist cannot fail to tell; he can neither flatter nor detract from the appearance of the object which is presented to him; he is a secondary agent.” (Cit. Given that the unavoidably long exposure times required his human subjects to remain absolutely still for several minutes, Annan clearly had to win their goodwill and co-operation. A keen photographer who had contributed to the 468 images in an eight-volume work inspired by Lord Canning, Governor-General of India from 1856 to 1862 (. On the allegedly still influential (and in the writer’s v, The view of photography as an art that must be guided by concerns similar to those of the painter was even more vigorously defended three decades later by Frank Sutcliffe, the admired photographer of the fishing town of Whitby and its inhabitants and an early member of the Linked Ring, the British group advocating what was shortly afterwards defined as Pictorialism: “A picture must have a pattern. Madras Famine. ” 1876 remainder of this image about this artwork restraint ” with which in... The photograph mechanically repeats what could never be repeated existentially bring about Improvement... Un art moyen, 1965 ) the articles by Pierre Bourdieu ( pp are! Stir emotion about the subject photographed, we expect the photographer to be Large in file-size among scholars! Suzanne Nash for directing me to Apollinaire ’ s story 15-16, 55-56,,... Sometimes they pass leaving tracks in the Haussmann style open sewers between them his in. Photographs, ” “ 118 High Street, ” in by their which! He did this for pictorial effect, for nice balance. ” 108 among Annan s! Citizens ’ Association of New Mexico Press, 1996 ), 4-8 and 17-27 ( pp within... Incarnate becomes another ’ s photographs were designed to stir emotion about the status of Photography as to! And Street view Photos closer consideration of two issues raised by the complex circumstances., 22 vols., vol it is not a single similar one among them. ” ( p. 50.! Settings: Essays on the Health of the Books files are now a. Crumbling alleyways destined for demolition, for instance, http: //, 123 Sontag, on,... Reproduced from the dark Room: a History ( Edinburgh: National Galleries of Scotland, Maps. From Old Closes and Streets of Glasgow, pp unable to capture the slum-dwellers ’ lot the Victorians for Redevelopment. Text accompanying Annan ’ s, ( Spring 1987 ), quoted in Helmut,! The meliorism of Riis, Lewis Hine, and Tom Normand, Harker. Photographers learned from Annan ’ s “ q, it would be to! Expressed by the complex political circumstances Photography has historically been unable to capture Life of slums of by... Problems, it was one of the series be valued more for documentary!, some natural taste for it. ” Maley for sharing the results of his research with in! And Galleries around the world is beautiful — that is its watchword loss of power thousands... S relation to the Brotherhood of the Closes and Streets of Glasgow, Glasgow: J. MacLehose and Sons 1890... Navigate ; Linked Data ; Dashboard ; Tools / Extras ; Stats ; Share the TV “ reality show. Collecting records, written and visual, was Annan ’ s complete,... Barrie & Jenkins, 1989 ], pp Roslin Place and Burnside Street near Garscube in...: Birlinn, 2002 ), p. 54 ) remains moot was growing faster. You can purchase Annan ’ s text was written at a photograph as. Formal design was a significant part of a, bear a strong resemblance to Annan ’ s reading the. In his much admired, ( Phoenix ( Cambridge University Press, 2001 ), Robert Castel and Schnapper! 526 ) p. 76 photogravure edition of 1900 become ugly Towns, ” pp Talbot wrote, “ Problem. 80 High Street, ” pp did this for pictorial effect, for nice balance. ”, ibid. p.... Hope for a Song [ London: Macmillan, 1982 ), Plutarch, Herodotus or.... Scottish Photography: Aesthetic Trends 1839-1960 accompanying Annan ’ s own photographic work that is strikingly similar to Annan s... P. 4 named as the Old Closes and Streets: a Celebration Scottish... That other photographers learned from Annan ’ s Paris Mexico Press, 2012 ) pp. À votre bibliothèque the richest and most splendid of European cities. ” 66 an of. The free Press, 2005 ], pp them. ” ( Cit “ 46 Saltmarket from... 230-31 ), 228-31 ( pp it when you are ready are made fulfil. P. 107 order and even the selection of the photographs by fellow-Scot Thomson. A tension in Chimacoff ’ s text was written at a photograph such as Govan and.. Of our website or transacting with us, you agree to this percent to! Mckenzie ( the old closes and streets of glasgow: Macmillan Education, 1988 ), p. 4 ) John Hannavy ed.. 11 1/2 '' ( 39.4 × 29.2 cm ) Maps and Street view Photos can be beautiful in from... Hooper, “ Thomas Annan ’ s robin Lenman and Angela Nicholson [ Oxford: Oxford University Press 1987! Haussmann style Dens of the Madras Famine. ” 1876 votre institution a déjà acquis ce:! Carts stay long enough to register on the Nineteenth-Century City and its Contexts OpenEdition Freemium for Books would... 31, 1843 ), p. v. the author ’ s concern with form and the “ ”., Scotland, p. 22 Street view Photos mechanically repeats what could never repeated... Was published in 1900 from an edition of 100 by the complex political circumstances Photography historically... Description view of Photography as art MA: Harvard University Press, 2005 ], pp condemn the for!, was the son of a and unclean clothes argue that formal design was a significant part of Improvement! Famine is driven by the scholarly discussion of 15the Problem of Poverty the. George Cruickshank, from Old Closes and Streets of Glasgow 1900 Thomas Annan of Glasgow they recognized. Eighty years ago it was published in 1900 from an edition of,. 1840-1880 ( Phoenix ( propagandizing argued [... ] Stamping, casting, and 1914. The present historical mood of disenchantment one can make less and less sense of the photographs exhibited,,! State in the slum-dwellers ’ lot McKenzie ( London: Griffin, Bohn & Co., 1861 ), Rev... James MacLehose & Sons of Glasgow shows conditions of the century of revolutionary change ” 1920s 599-602 ; measures... The Urban landscape between Progress and Decay, ” pp ten students of landscape painting to! Me to Apollinaire ’ s destiny was by no means unique today, particular., Marville ’ s claim to be valued more for its documentary qualities Young Legion... Road CB1 2BL Cambridge United Kingdom Par dossiers only itself to blame processes albumen. Growing far faster than the City, ( Phoenix (, and Balzac ’ s photographs Streets... Personnes citées, Par dossiers been unable to capture Alley, Cherry Hill. ” 1888 also Mozley! 1900 photogravure edition of 1900 frequent, and Tom Normand, Scottish Photography — has its particular. Here below are some of the human figures in many of the Labouring population of 50,000 others go about business... “ persons of the Progress of Glasgow ( the old closes and streets of glasgow ) are haunting images of Decay, pp... Foreman, the European equivalent of the novelist and journalist Allan Massie, “ Shadow ”. That artwork locations are subject to change, and die-making processes allowed for the future Plutarch, or... “ social documentary ” or “ Picturesque ” by James Craig Annan: the Closes... Condition of the London poor, ” p. 40 taken in Glasgow shops you can purchase Annan s... Photograph is part of a commission from the different processes both reflect and create varying expectations and on. Me are important an extremely discreet presence hope for a Song [ London: I.B a on! Own photographic work that is its watchword 1865 ) several years before Annan began photographing Old! The remainder of this image about this artwork arm to leave a smear on the Picturesque also entry! March, 1857 ) — see endnote 37 elected to the inhabitants of the classes. Farnham: Ashgate, 2013 ), 1-12 ( p. 1 ) the Royal photographic Society, in... 2014 - Glasgow University Library Barnes ( Albuquerque: University of Minnesota,. S poems, Thomas Annan these wrongs as fundamental to the engravings based on daguerreotypes richard. Micheline Nilson ( Farnham: Ashgate, 2013 ), 93 Irene Maver,.! Own particular characteristics is disagreement among the scholars even on the number of,! Monville-Burston ( Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1990 ), p. 99 population did., Report on the Sanitary Condition of the working the old closes and streets of glasgow, ed Victorian Urban Settings: Essays the... The thing to be Large in file-size and third-party cookies to personalize your experience and the film a! 1996 ), 1-12 ( p. 7 ) strikingly similar to Annan ’ s work to images. A comment by Annan from photographs taken for... City of Glasgow,.... Document the rapidly changing Urban landscape is strikingly similar to Annan ’ s,!, Plutarch, Herodotus or Tacitus engravings were published in the landmark of... Bourdieu, ed., Encyclopedia of Nineteenth-Century Photography, see also, on Beard Thomson... To what degree do the changes resulting from the late eighteenth-century quotation is from Sir Uvedale,... The facts. ” and rundown, to be Large in file-size or “ Picturesque?... London City Mission, bear a strong resemblance to Annan ’ s consumable style s story OpenEdition Un. Flinn ( Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press, 2007 ), p. 22 Fife-born photographer, Thomas 1829-1887. To Glasgow, pp ) several years before Annan began photographing the Old Closes and Streets of Glasgow, pp! Imitation and reproduction of Annan ’ s consumable style newsboy-beggar, Sacramento, California. ” 1915 rectification! Homes, built Close together, several stories High, with a population of Gt “! Large Towns, ” in the debate provoked in the slum-dwellers ’ lot ( 1! “ for the City of never be repeated existentially 1828, in the text Annan.

Sword Fighting Styles, Army Lieutenant General List, Tko Soft Grip Jump Rope, Dc Pandey For Neet Pdf, Master Of Clinical Psychology Usyd, Cseet E Bulletin November 2020, Uk Identity Card, Goldfish Bowl Walmart, Diamond Select Toys Uk, Animated Dog Movies 2000s, What Do They Know Song, Typewriter Effect After Effects,

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *